Collison's Bombshell: The Political Betrayal Killing Ireland's Future

Stripe co-founder John Collison has delivered an exclusive, breaking analysis of Ireland’s crisis, revealing a shocking truth: a nation booming in population is failing to build the basics.

Since 1990, Ireland’s population has exploded from 3.5 million to 5.5 million—a growth rate faster than almost any other country in the EU. Yet, despite this massive boom, we now have the continent’s second-fewest homes per person. How can a nation with such talent and wealth be going backwards on the most fundamental necessities of life?

This isn’t a failure of money or ambition; it’s a political failure, and it directly impacts your family, your commute, and your future. We have forgotten the basics of running a country, and the consequences are devastating.

The Invisible Crisis Killing Your Quality of Life

The infrastructure crisis is not a distant problem; it’s happening now. Dublin’s water network is projected to hit its limits in just three years, a bottleneck that will stop housing construction dead in its tracks. Meanwhile, your household electricity prices are already the highest in Europe.

Think about the human cost. Grandchildren are forced to live hours from their grandparents. Students lose out on vital university life because they can’t afford to live near campus. Many of us are trapped in three-hour daily commutes. This stress frays the social fabric of the country, driving anger and political polarization.

The facts are stark and infuriating: Ireland has 41 percent fewer trains, roads, and transport infrastructure per capita than other high-income European countries. We have the lowest proportion of electrified rail in the entire EU. This is the price of forgetting how to build.

The Bureaucratic Logjam Revealed

The core of the problem, according to Collison, is a political system that has deliberately ceded control, creating a “government-by-agency” logjam. In a bombshell finding, he notes that since 2000, the State has created a staggering 303 new government agencies, quangos, or departments—compared to only 74 in the preceding 25 years.

This proliferation of agencies has reassigned power from elected politicians—who are accountable to you—to an unelected Civil Service. Collison argues that this “constrained power” is being conflated with good governance, allowing difficult trade-offs to be avoided and chronic problems to remain unfixed. Our politicians are on autopilot, and you are paying the price.

Naming the Agencies That Block Progress

The result is a system where a single-issue agency can veto a massive national infrastructure project. This combinatorial complexity creates an impenetrable web of bureaucracy.

Specific agencies are actively blocking progress across the country. An Taisce, for instance, has blocked the Galway ring road, the M3 motorway, and the critical Shannon LNG scheme. Officials at Fingal County Council have been throttling flights out of Dublin Airport, while Inland Fisheries Ireland has blocked essential flood remediation works. Even the Heritage Council is blocking the demolition of a wall for the N2 bypass.

These bodies, in the pursuit of their narrow goals, create a paralyzing logjam that prevents the common good from being served. You feel the injustice of this every day.

How to Seize Back Control and Build

Collison’s exclusive solution is a clear, actionable path to get Ireland moving again. It requires politicians to reverse the power drain and re-embrace their role as leaders who make difficult, necessary trade-offs.

To break the planning deadlock, he calls for a specialized fast-track court dedicated solely to planning judicial reviews. This would stop endless, costly delays. Furthermore, he proposes updated primary legislation for compulsory purchase orders and a higher land-value tax on zoned development land. This crucial economic lever would force land-hoarders to “use it or lose it,” unlocking desperately needed construction sites.

This is a political fight for the soul of the nation. It is a demand to stop managing decline and start building a future that matches our economic success. Do we continue to accept a system that puts bureaucratic process over the needs of 5.5 million people, or do we finally re-empower our leaders to build the Ireland we deserve?

Background and Context

Background and Context

The analysis delivered by John Collison is fundamentally an indictment of Ireland’s structural capacity and its governing class’s failure to translate immense private sector wealth into functional public infrastructure. To understand the gravity of Collison’s “bombshell,” it is essential to contextualize the extraordinary economic and demographic forces that have reshaped the Republic of Ireland since the late 20th century.

The Double-Edged Sword of Prosperity

Ireland’s modern history is defined by two profound shifts. The first was the ‘Celtic Tiger’ era, beginning in the mid-1990s, which transformed the nation from a historically poor, indebted, and emigration-plagued state into a global hub for technology, pharmaceuticals, and finance. This success was built primarily on attracting Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) through competitive corporate tax rates, creating hundreds of thousands of high-value jobs. This success persists today, evidenced by Ireland’s status as the European headquarters for giants like Collison’s own Stripe, Google, Apple, and Meta, generating phenomenal tax receipts and yielding one of the highest GDP figures per capita globally.

However, this spectacular economic growth—a growth fundamentally dependent on a highly mobile international workforce—required constant, matching investment in foundational national infrastructure. This investment largely failed to materialise after the 2008 financial crash, and successive governments, while benefiting from the economic recovery and increasing population, neglected the core mandate of national planning.

The Demographic Shockwave

The second critical shift is the unprecedented demographic acceleration that forms the crux of Collison’s statistical evidence. In 1990, the population of the Republic of Ireland stood at approximately 3.5 million. By the most recent estimates, that figure has soared to approximately 5.5 million people—an increase of nearly 57% in just over three decades. This is not organic, slow growth; it is a seismic demographic event unparalleled in modern Western Europe.

This explosive growth is fuelled by several simultaneous factors: a significant return of the Irish diaspora following decades of emigration; consistently high birth rates relative to other EU nations; and, crucially, high net inward migration driven by the demands of the FDI economy. The need for engineers, tech professionals, healthcare workers, and construction labour to sustain the economic engine necessitates a steady influx of international residents.

The political system, however, has consistently failed to accept the permanency of this new, larger population base. Instead of adopting long-term planning mechanisms commensurate with a 5.5 million-person economy—and planning for a trajectory towards 6 million—policy has remained reactive, often treating infrastructural needs

as temporary or cyclical issues.

The Housing Paradox: Scarcity Amidst Super-Wealth

The most visible manifestation of this failure is the housing crisis, which Collison highlights using the damning metric of homes per person. Ireland now stands as one of the most structurally undersupplied nations in the EU in terms of accommodation units relative to its population. Where nations like Spain or France boast housing stock sufficient for historical population peaks and provide buffers, Ireland’s housing count severely lags behind demand.

This shortage is not merely inconvenient; it is functionally corrosive. It drives catastrophic rental inflation, forces young workers into perpetual dependency, hampers social mobility, and actively threatens Ireland’s economic competitiveness by making it prohibitively expensive for skilled foreign workers to relocate. The crisis has metastasised beyond housing, impacting healthcare capacity, public transport systems (where delays in delivering projects like the Dublin Metro run into decades), and the provision of basic utilities, underscoring the systemic failure to build the “basics” that a sophisticated, modern economy demands.

Collison’s intervention, originating from a figure deeply embedded in the mechanics of global business efficiency, shifts the narrative from traditional political blame to an engineering critique: Ireland is a fantastically rich country that has engineered a failure of supply and planning, effectively betraying the future opportunities promised by its own economic success. This background of profound growth met by profound policy inertia sets the stage for the accusation of political betrayal.

Key Developments

Key Developments

John Collison’s groundbreaking analysis cuts through the celebratory narrative of Ireland’s GDP figures, focusing instead on the catastrophic failure to translate economic success into basic societal capacity. The key developments fueling this crisis are rooted in a uniquely Irish combination of explosive demographic growth, systemic planning failures, and a political apparatus paralyzed by short-term electoral considerations.

The Unprecedented Demographic Surge

The primary development driving the current crisis is the sheer scale and speed of Ireland’s population expansion. Since 1990, the population surged by 57%, moving from 3.5 million to an estimated 5.5 million today. This growth rate is unmatched by almost all comparable EU nations. This expansion was initially driven by the “Celtic Tiger” returning diaspora and immigration, coupled with sustained higher-than-average birth rates. Post-2015, the growth has continued unabated, fuelled by high net migration driven by Ireland’s successful Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) strategy.

Collison highlights that this unprecedented demographic pressure was met not with accelerated infrastructure development, but with deceleration. While countries undergoing similar population booms historically prioritize massive investment in housing, transport, and utilities, Ireland did the opposite. The period between 2010 and 2020 saw construction activity—especially large-scale public and affordable housing—effectively cease, creating a structural deficit that now requires immediate, enormous correction. This failure established the core paradox: a nation boasting world-leading multinationals and immense private wealth possesses the continent’s second-lowest housing density per capita.

Policy Paralysis and the Planning Trap

The most devastating key development identified by Collison is the systematic political failure to reform the nation’s outdated and crippling planning framework. The analysis posits that Ireland’s crisis is not a lack of money or expertise, but a lack of political will to overcome vested interests and regulatory gridlock. The current system empowers local opposition—often termed NIMBYism (Not In My Backyard)—to stall, obstruct, or outright kill essential housing and infrastructure projects through complex regulatory processes and lengthy judicial reviews.

This “planning trap” means that even high-density, strategic projects designed to address the housing deficit take years longer to gain approval in Ireland than in peer nations. This inefficiency acts as a massive tax on development, driving up construction costs, discouraging institutional investors, and ensuring that the supply of new homes chronically lags behind demand. Political parties, fearful of antagonizing powerful local pressure groups in swing constituencies, have consistently failed to implement necessary, centralized planning reforms that would prioritize national strategic goals over hyper-local resistance. The result is a system of “soft corruption” where political expediency trumps the needs of the younger, working population.

The Economic and Generational Betrayal

Finally, Collison’s bombshell underscores the long-term economic betrayal implicit in this inaction. The infrastructure deficit is now beginning to actively undermine the highly successful FDI model. Multinational corporations are struggling to house high-value staff, leading to inflated wage costs and significant recruitment difficulties. As Collison notes, if Ireland cannot offer a basic quality of life—affordable housing, functional public services—its competitive edge rapidly erodes.

The cost of this betrayal is borne disproportionately by younger generations. They face crippling rent burdens, delayed home ownership, and a perceived drop in living standards compared to their parents’ generation, despite historic economic output. This generational injustice is leading to an increasing “brain drain,” reversing decades of progress as talented young Irish citizens emigrate to countries that can provide basic necessities. The failure to build is not merely an inconvenience; it is a structural crisis that threatens to choke off future growth, fundamentally eroding the social contract that underpins Irish prosperity.

Data and Evidence

Data and Evidence: The Decades of Decline

John Collison’s assessment is not merely anecdotal; it is a meticulous dismantling of the official narrative, backed by stark, irrefutable data points that reveal decades of systemic failure in managing Ireland’s demographic boom. The core of the crisis lies in the unprecedented divergence between population growth and infrastructural delivery, particularly in housing, healthcare, and transport.

The Housing Catastrophe: An International Anomaly

The most damning evidence is found in the housing sector. Since 1990, Ireland’s population grew by approximately 57%. This level of growth—a staggering increase of 2 million people in three decades—is comparable only to rapidly expanding, traditionally high-immigration economies like Luxembourg or Switzerland, yet Ireland’s response has been uniquely insufficient.

Comparative Housing Stock: Collison highlighted the critical metric: homes per 1,000 population. Ireland currently ranks second-to-last in the European Union on this key indicator, trailing behind countries that are far less wealthy and experiencing slower growth rates. According to Eurostat and OECD data, Ireland has approximately 400 homes per 1,000 residents, significantly below the EU average of roughly 480. This deficit means that even if Ireland stopped growing today, it would need to build an additional 400,000 homes just to reach the EU average provision. The data confirms that successive governments have not just failed to keep up with growth, they have allowed the existing deficit to deepen exponentially.

Residential Construction Output: Analysis of residential completions provides a clear timeline of the failure. Following the 2008 financial crisis, while construction plummeted globally, Ireland’s recovery was uniquely slow and stunted in the residential sector. In 2011, Ireland built less than 10,000 homes. Even in the record-breaking year of 2023, with over 32,000 completions, this output remains dramatically below the estimated annual demand (often cited between 40,000 and 50,000 units) required merely to stabilize prices and accommodate demographic pressures. Crucially, in the period between 2010 and 2020, Ireland built fewer homes per capita than most of its European peers, locking the current generation into a perpetual housing scarcity crisis.

Infrastructure Paralysis and Urban Congestion

The strain extends far beyond housing, exposing a holistic failure of strategic planning. The core thesis of Collison’s bombshell is that public policy has allowed population growth to accelerate without mandatory accompanying investment in enabling infrastructure.

Commuting Times and Productivity: Data from the Central Statistics Office (CSO) reveals the consequences of transport underinvestment. Average commuting times in Ireland’s major urban centers, particularly Dublin, have soared. Dublin regularly features in global rankings as one of the most traffic-congested cities in Western Europe. This congestion is not just a quality-of-life issue; it is a measurable drag on economic productivity. Research suggests that the annual cost of traffic congestion to the Irish economy runs into billions of euros, wasted in idle time, delayed logistics, and increased carbon emissions. While countries like the Netherlands and Germany have systematically expanded metropolitan rail and public transport networks to absorb similar urban population surges, Ireland has relied disproportionately on road infrastructure expansion which is rapidly overwhelmed by demand.

Healthcare Overload: The crisis manifests sharply in healthcare provision. Despite massive increases in health spending, the efficiency of the Irish system has declined relative to population size. Data on hospital bed capacity is alarming. Ireland currently has one of the lowest acute bed capacities per capita in the OECD. Furthermore, the number of GPs per 100,000 population is struggling to keep pace, especially in rapidly expanding commuter areas. The resulting symptoms—record-breaking waiting lists and perpetual overcrowding in Emergency Departments—are direct, measurable outcomes of the political failure to match infrastructural provision with demographic reality. The data confirms the central tragedy: a wealthier, more numerous population is receiving poorer basic public services than their predecessors.

• Tags:
• Government